Framework for selecting best practices in public health: a systematic literature review

https://doi.org/10.4081/jphr.2015.577

  • Eileen Ng
    University of Oxford, United Kingdom.
  • Pierpaolo de Colombani
    World Health Organization Regional Office for Europe, Copenhagen, Denmark.

ABSTRACT

Evidence-based public health has commonly relied on findings from empirical studies, or research-based evidence. However, this paper advocates that practice-based evidence derived from programmes implemented in real-life settings is likely to be a more suitable source of evidence for inspiring and guiding public health programmes. Selection of best practices from the array of implemented programmes is one way of generating such practice-based evidence. Yet the lack of consensus on the definition and criteria for practice-based evidence and best practices has limited their application in public health so far. To address the gap in literature on practice-based evidence, this paper hence proposes measures of success for public health interventions by developing an evaluation framework for selection of best practices. The proposed framework was synthesised from a systematic literature review of peer-reviewed and grey literature on existing evaluation frameworks for public health programmes as well as processes employed by health-related organisations when selecting best practices. A best practice is firstly defined as an intervention that has shown evidence of effectiveness in a particular setting and is likely to be replicable to other situations. Regardless of the area of public health, interventions should be evaluated by their context, process and outcomes. A best practice should hence meet most, if not all, of eight identified evaluation criteria: relevance, community participation, stakeholder collaboration, ethical soundness, replicability, effectiveness, efficiency and sustainability. Ultimately, a standardised framework for selection of best practices will improve the usefulness and credibility of practice-based evidence in informing evidence-based public health interventions.

Tomoko Takayama, Chikako Yamaki, Masayo Hayakawa, Takahiro Higashi, Yasushi Toh, Fumihiko Wakao (2021)

Development of a New Tool for Better Social Recognition of Cancer Information and Support Activities Under the National Cancer Control Policy in Japan. Journal of Public Health Management and Practice, 27(2), E87.
10.1097/PHH.0000000000001155

Charlotte V. Farewell, Jini E. Puma, Jamie Powers, Elaine S. Belansky (2018)

Assess, Identify, Make it Happen (AIM) for Preschools: A Tool to Decrease Early Childhood Obesity. Health Promotion Practice, 19(6), 935.
10.1177/1524839917746677

Yvette H Beulen, Anouk Geelen, Jeanne HM de Vries, Sabina Super, Maria A Koelen, Edith JM Feskens, Annemarie Wagemakers (2020)

Optimizing Low–Socioeconomic Status Pregnant Women’s Dietary Intake in the Netherlands: Protocol for a Mixed-Methods Study. JMIR Research Protocols, 9(2), e14796.
10.2196/14796

Pablo Varela‐Centelles, Pedro Diz‐Iglesias, Ana Estany‐Gestal, Andrés Blanco‐Hortas, Rosendo Bugarín‐González, Juan M. Seoane‐Romero, Juan Blanco (2019)

Periodontal awareness and what it actually means: A cross‐sectional study. Oral Diseases, 25(3), 831.
10.1111/odi.13026

Kimberly Hook, Elizabeth Vera (2020)

Best Practices in Global Mental Health: An Exploratory Study of Recommendations for Psychologists. International Perspectives in Psychology, 9(2), 67.
10.1037/ipp0000125

Wanrudee Isaranuwatchai, Yot Teerawattananon, Rachel A Archer, Alia Luz, Manushi Sharma, Waranya Rattanavipapong, Thunyarat Anothaisintawee, Rachel L Bacon, Tazeem Bhatia, Jesse Bump, Kalipso Chalkidou, Adam G Elshaug, David D Kim, Sumithra Krishnamurthy Reddiar, Ryota Nakamura, Peter J Neumann, Arisa Shichijo, Peter C Smith, Anthony J Culyer (2020)

Prevention of non-communicable disease: best buys, wasted buys, and contestable buys. BMJ, m141.
10.1136/bmj.m141

Charlotte V. Farewell, Jini Puma, Mondi A. Mason, Paula Peirce, Michele Shimomura, Megan Harms (2020)

Training Child Care Inspectors to Deliver Health Messaging: A Quality Improvement Pilot Project. Health Promotion Practice, 21(2), 188.
10.1177/1524839918786952

Susanne Hartung (2021)

Public Health. Sozialwissenschaftliche Gesundheitsforschung, 349.
10.1007/978-3-658-30377-8_19

Walter Ricciardi, Fidelia Cascini (2021)

Textbook of Patient Safety and Clinical Risk Management. 3.
10.1007/978-3-030-59403-9_1

Shoukat H. Qari, Mary R. Leinhos, Tracy N. Thomas, Eric G. Carbone (2018)

Overview of the Translation, Dissemination, and Implementation of Public Health Preparedness and Response Research and Training Initiative. American Journal of Public Health, 108(S5), S355.
10.2105/AJPH.2018.304709

Jennifer Marks, Lisa M. Barnett, Steven Allender (2019)

Is school community perception of student weight status a barrier for addressing childhood obesity?. Health Promotion Journal of Australia, 30(1), 28.
10.1002/hpja.172

Jennifer Alvidrez, Anna María Nápoles, Guillermo Bernal, Jacqueline Lloyd, Victoria Cargill, Dionne Godette, Lisa Cooper, Maria Yellow Horse Brave Heart, Rina Das, Tilda Farhat (2019)

Building the Evidence Base to Inform Planned Intervention Adaptations by Practitioners Serving Health Disparity Populations. American Journal of Public Health, 109(S1), S94.
10.2105/AJPH.2018.304915

Kathleen E. Krieger, Deborah A. Gibbs, Stacey L. Cutbush (2020)

Evaluating Human Trafficking Service Programs: What Can Be Learned from Domestic Violence Service Program Evaluations. Journal of Human Trafficking, 1.
10.1080/23322705.2020.1784686

Mai O’Leary, Elaine Rush, Seán Lacey, Con Burns, Tara Coppinger (2019)

Project Spraoi: two year outcomes of a whole school physical activity and nutrition intervention using the RE-AIM framework. Irish Educational Studies, 38(2), 219.
10.1080/03323315.2019.1567368

Viktoria A Kovacs, Eszter Sarkadi-Nagy, Petru Sandu, Vesselka Duleva, Angela Spinelli, Csilla Kaposvari, Maria Hassapidou, Dilani Janssen, Elżbieta Grochowska-Niedworok, Sven Messing, Eva Martos (2018)

Good practice criteria for childhood obesity prevention in kindergartens and schools—elaboration, content and use. European Journal of Public Health, 28(6), 1029.
10.1093/eurpub/cky129

Omri Besor, Orly Manor, Ora Paltiel, Milka Donchin, Orly Rauch, Vered Kaufman-Shriqui (2020)

A city-wide health promotion programme evaluation using EQUIHP: Jerusalem Community-Academic Partnership (J-CAP). European Journal of Public Health, 30(3), 427.
10.1093/eurpub/ckz154